While it may not be easy, navigating a church through transitions can be a positive opportunity for congregations to develop a renewed sense of identity in Christ, Aaron Summers shared in a Tuesday morning workshop at the Annual Meeting.
While Summers serves as director of Pastorless Churches for Texas Baptists, he noted early in the workshop that transitions can happen for several reasons, and diagnosing the injury is key to healing and moving forward positively.
“Transition is hard, and working through it is hard, but if we let the church muscles atrophy, it will create more trouble down the road. Clinicians call it guarding, and the body chooses that response naturally. The muscles and tissues want to grip up, and you have to work that out to get healing going,” said Summers, using physical therapy analogies throughout. “There is a subtle shift: the church begins to ask ‘What is safe’ rather than ‘What is faithful?’ In a healthy moment, the church would take the risk, those leaps of faith, and go with God. But in a moment of transition when things are more difficult, we start to guard ourselves.”
Summers said transition can come from five basic reasons, not the least of which is losing a pastor, whether long beloved or not. It could also come from succession, where the incoming pastor is being trained up, and there is great comparison; revitalization, where years of decline create fatigue among members; replant, which creates a strain amid a changing community; and rapid change, which can overload a church whether it is positive or negative.
The key to any of this is for a pastor – whether interim, new or existing – to stick to the key elements to move forward.
“A pastor who sees rebellion will fight his people; a pastor who sees a wound will help them heal. They may resist when they are guarded,” he said. “If you walk with them and love them, listen to them and learn from them, then you can lead them. If you flip those around, it’s going to be a difficult time.”
He suggested that key steps must be taken to help congregations in transition, no matter what the root cause. The first is stabilization, which means leaders remain steady and calm and take the time to be with people and listen to members who will borrow that same calm. As Summers noted, ordinary consistency from a leader builds credibility. He also suggested that predictable rhythms lead to security and eliminate fear among members.
“Leaders, I beg you: predictable rhythms are not wrong. They’re probably more secure for your people, and it’s easier to lead them spiritually,” he said. “We often think it’s bad to be ‘plain vanilla,’ but being plain vanilla is exactly what the people need. They are able to understand they can count on you.”
A key step in healing, Summers said, is reorienting the mission, which may have shifted due to a changed neighborhood, city demographics and new generations.
“Your church isn’t dying necessarily; you have all these people in the community that you have to learn to see again,” he said. “We want to mourn the loss of who we used to be. So we need to be moving the congregation from a mourning bench into an active harvest field.”
Summers suggested asking four questions as a congregation: What’s going right? What is going wrong? What are we confused about? What is missing?
Restoring agency is the next step, where a leader moves the church from consumer mode, where members are an audience waiting for leaders to perform, to one of stewardship where they participate their way into ownership and realize the church is their responsibility as a whole.
He said breaking this paralysis often requires replacing the traditional five-year plan with the “next faithful step” and taking smaller moves. It may also be best to try new ideas as pilot experiments for 90 days, giving people an easy way to evaluate programs and test them to lower the threat. Finally, leaders should allow stumbles, but never stoppage.
Reaching stability is a good thing, but Summers warned that it is not the finish line. Instead, much like a hospital discharge, it is the start of living.
“God never restores the church to rest. He restores it to participate in mission,” he said.
Keys to healthy churches in transition, Summers said, are moving from the pastor being a centralized hero that owns every initiative and the lid on the church’s discipleship to being an equipping catalyst that empowers the saints for ministry and celebrates their wins.
Finally, Summers said it is vital to follow the Antioch metric, where health is measured not by who stays in the room but by who is being deployed and sent into mission.
“Recovery is not returning to who we were before the mountain. It is becoming the congregation God is making today,” he said in closing.
Strengthening a multiplying movement of churches to live out the Great Commandment and Great Commission in Texas and beyond.
The ministry of Texas Baptists is made possible by giving through the Texas Baptists Cooperative Program, Mary Hill Davis Offering® for Texas Missions, Texas Baptists Worldwide and Texas Baptist Missions Foundation. Thank you for your faithful and generous support.
Subscribe to receive stories like this one directly to your inbox.
We are more together.